Print

DAY 2 -- Find and Develop Your Best Site Concept

SBI! Module Used Today -- Brainstorm It!

Action Guide - Idea Your DAY 2 goal is to find your best Site Concept.

Video Demo Home Page

Prefer to watch?

Click here to access the Action Guide Videos!

Prefer to read? You have 2 choices...

Continue reading this full version of DAY 2. It is long, but complete. Take your time. Work through it steadily.

Or... Click here for the condensed DAY 2.

It will get you where you need to go, too (minus a few details and fine points).

Today's Action Steps

Action Guide - Action StepsThe rest of your business rides on your choice of Site Concept.

So let's do it right.

Here is how you will get to your Best Site Concept...

  1. Create a list of potential Site Concepts and choose your top 3
    • Everyone Knows Something About Something
    • Three Site Concepts? Why Three?
    • Do Some Quick Research Before Brainstorm It!
  2. Use Brainstorm It! to research Site Concept(s). Brainstorm keywords for your top 3 Site Concepts. Analyze their Value Demand and Real Supply.
  3. Evaluate the following factors for each Site Concept...
  4. Use Niche Choose It! to help find the best Site Concept for you.

At the end of DAY 2, do a quick review of the Business-Building Checklist. (Adobe Reader is needed.)

"Value Demand" is a combination of how often people search for a particular keyword and how monetizable or commercial that keyword is. The best words (i.e., the highest Value Demand) have a high search volume AND are highly commercial.

This measure of Demand is called "Value Demand" because it both provides a better estimate of Demand AND includes a reflection of how important the Demand for each keyword is, in terms of its commercial potential. More on this below.

"Real Supply" is a score for a keyword that indicates how competitive that keyword is, compared to the others in your Master Keyword List. It provides a rough idea of how difficult it will be to rank in the Top 10 at the engines.

The higher the Real Supply, the more competitive the situation. This measure of Supply is called "Real" because it provides a true evaluation of competition for each keyword. More on this below.

The "Profitability" of each keyword is its Value Demand divided by its Real Supply times 1,000. The ideal keyword has HIGH Value Demand and LOW Real Supply. The more keywords (for a given Site Concept) that have higher Value Demand and lower Real Supply (and therefore higher Profitability -- Value Demand/Real Supply ratio), the better is the "overall Profitability" of that Site Concept.

Important: This is not an absolute, just an indication. Use your human judgement to make the final decision -- do not become number-bound. In general, though, the higher a keyword's Profitability, the better. This is especially important when Supply is fairly large. The smaller the Supply number, the less importance you should put on Profitability.

The "Overall Profitability" of a niche is the Value Demand divided by the Real Supply of a large number of the keywords returned for that niche. The ideal Site Concept has HIGH Value Demand and LOW Real Supply for many of its keywords. The more keywords (for a given Site Concept) that have higher Value Demand and lower Real Supply, the better is the "Overall Profitability" of that Site Concept.

Important: This is not an absolute, just an indication. Use your human judgement to make the final decision -- do not become number-bound. Read this article about judging profitability.

A Site Concept Keyword with good Niche Depth has a Supply range that is winnable (acceptable competition) and with a reasonable number of keywords with good Demand (greater than 1,000).

Ready?

Here we go. The "going" is about to get a bit heavier. That's normal. You are building a business here, a real business. And there are two fundamental laws that the Web does not suspend...

  1. The Law of Gravity: Things still fall to the ground.
  2. The Law of Business: It still takes work to build a real business with real equity. The good news is that SBI! does eliminate all the technology, accelerating your pace and allowing you to focus only on your business.

Action Guide -- Hammer Proceed steadily step-by-step. Take your time. Remember, a "DAY" is just a metaphor in SBI!. You completed DAY 1 in mere minutes. DAY 2 may take days, even weeks. So don't worry if your head spins at first.

Take your time. Watch the Action Guide videos. Read the help. And click on the definition links where provided (click here for an example).

This is an example of a definition link. A yellow box will open over top of the Action Guide or help page, with a definition or more information.

If you ever feel overwhelmed, that comes from wanting to do it all immediately. It takes energy and time to pick "just the right niche." Making the right decision will be worth every minute you invest during DAY 2.

Proceed with patience and perseverance. There is a reason that the tortoise is the SBI! mascot.

"Tortoise It!"... and your business will indeed "resist gravity" and soar.

This TNT article will help dispel any mental blocks you may have about getting started...

http://sbitips.sitesell.com/get-started.html

Action Guide -- Smile So SBI! does help with both laws after all.

What Is a Site Concept?

Dictionary.com defines a niche as... 1) A situation or activity specially suited to a person's interests, abilities, or nature: ex., "found her niche in life." 2) A special area of demand for a product or service: ex., "niche magazines."

First, a Site Concept is a keyword. You use it to write the content of your home page.

It is also the central theme, the niche, upon which you will base all of your site's content (hence the term "Theme-Based Content Site"). Every page that you write will be about a topic that is related to your Site Concept. Each one of those topical pages focuses on a Specific Keyword, which is why we also call these pages Keyword-Focused Content Pages ("KFCPs").

Keyword: The term a surfer enters into a Search Engine when searching for something. These would be words like...

"Anguilla" and "Anguilla villas" and "Caribbean vacations."

(The term "keyword" includes single words as well as multi-word phrases. Most searches are not actually single-word searches. Why? Because most searchers quickly learn to enter two or more words in their searches in order to get better (more precise) results. We call that entry a "keyword" even if it has 5 words in it.)

A keyword is also the topic for the content of a Web page. All the other words on that page are "content"... information about that keyword/topic.

We call the keyword that you make the topic of a Web page the Specific Keyword for that page.

click here for more information about keywords.

On DAY 3, you will complete the brainstorm-and-research process of the Site Concept that you choose here on DAY 2. But first, now, let's find your Site Concept... your theme... your niche that you CAN master.

There is plenty of room for more than one Web site in any niche. Don't worry when you find competitors. You have a huge advantage, thanks to SBI! -- remember that 99% of small business sites fail, even the most gorgeous ones that cost $20,000 to build! So...

Action Guide -- SmileTortoise It! You will pass them all.

SBI! ensures that you will do it well. You focus on business, while SBI! takes care of all the technical and tedious headaches. It shows you how to position and write your Site Concept so that you "own your space." Think you can't write? SBI! even shows you how to write to PREsell... with originality and flair, in your own voice.

Not sure that you can write? If you have any doubts at all about whether you can write Content that others will value, SBI! will show you exactly how to do that. The best time to work on your writing skills is during a later DAY, during which we'll cover...

  1. how to write to communicate.
  2. how to develop your own "voice" with flair and substance.
  3. how to spin your site/biz/self into a unique position.
  4. how to honestly convince people to trust and like you.

The right time to cover this is just before you actually start to write your site. But, if you want to take a day off now and learn how to "write to PREsell," branch off here.

How To Recognize Your Best Site Concept

A great Site Concept must...

  1. be in demand. A reasonable number of people must be searching for information about your theme. If your theme is too narrow (ex., an unknown off-island-off-an-off-island in the Caribbean), there is not enough demand for you to monetize, even if your entire (too tiny) market finds you!
  2. not be too broad. If your Site Concept is too broad (high Real Supply), the competition will be severe. It will be difficult to win or reach top rankings at the Search Engines for this theme's keywords.

    For example, it is impossible to "own" the theme of "travel." Leave those super-broad themes to companies like expedia.com. Even the Site Concept of "Caribbean" is highly competitive. If you have 80 hours per week and are ready to work for a year, you might succeed. But creating a site about one of the islands is your best opportunity...

    • You most likely know a lot about one island. And that goes for "islands of knowledge," not just geographic islands!
    • The competition will be less intense. So it will be easier for your well-written content pages to rank highly with the free Search Engines.
    • Those who find you will be highly targeted. They will be much more interested in your content. It is far easier to PREsell those searching for topics ("keywords") related to narrow themes than broad ones.
  3. excite you. Choose something that you know and love (or that you are willing to find out more about). If you do that, writing lots of information-packed content pages becomes an easy pleasure instead of work. Think "passion" and "knowledge" -- if you have it, it will shine in your content.
  4. deliver high ROI potential. It must offer excellent options for monetizing traffic to your site. This ensures the ROI (Return on Investment) you want. Make every visitor to your site a possible income-generator.
  5. be in sync with the time you have available to work on your site (i.e., if you only have 1 hour per week to work on your new business, don't tackle a highly competitive niche -- more on this in the Site Concept Tolerance Range discussion).

Monetization

Monetization is the conversion of traffic into money. Think of 1,000 people visiting your Web site. Your goal is to convert as many as possible of them into income. The best way to do that is to develop several "monetization models" (ways to monetize).

Why? Because not all of them will be interested in your primary offering. Others will click on Google AdSense ads, some will be interested in a product for which you are an affiliate, and so forth. To maximize monetization, maximize the number of visitors who convert into some form of income. More on this below and on DAY 4.

You may not yet be sure of how you will monetize your SBI! site. Don't worry -- by the time you finish DAYs 2-4 (especially DAY 4), you will have a good monetization plan.

On the other hand, you may already know your primary monetization model (ex., selling your own product or professional service, or boosting an existing online or offline business). If so, your DAY 2 goal is to define and refine...

After all, your theme will be related to your product or service. So use today to find the most profitable aspect of it, the best way to position your offering. While doing that, do not put "$ blinders" on -- keep your eyes open for extra ways to monetize.

Merely understand the above factors for now. When the time comes (at the end of this DAY), SBI! provides you with a foolproof tool (Niche Choose It!) to gather and evaluate all these factors and then find the best Site Concept for you.

Bottom line on choosing your Site Concept?...

Action Guide -- Pointing It takes just as much time to build a low-potential business as a high-potential one. So invest the time now, get the Site Concept right, and you will maximize your returns later, earning far more income per hour invested down the road.

The Plan... How To Develop Your Best Site Concept

Most people fail in any business because they don't plan adequately. If you pick the wrong concept for your site, if you develop the wrong topics for your Web pages... you'll get the wrong results...

No traffic = No income.

This will not be your fate. Let's get to work on your Best Site Concept Plan...

Step 1 - Create a list of potential Site Concepts and choose your top 3.

Write down ideas for good Site Concepts as they hit you, or record them into your cell phone, or type them into a journal on your computer. Make your list as long as you can. What do you know and love? What have you learned "on the job?" As you read the daily newspaper, or watch a talk show on TV, or chat with friends/colleagues, or browse a book store, keep your antennae up for new ideas.

Think... you may know so much about something that you overlook it.

For example, one SBIer once wrote to SiteSell Support to say that she knew very little about anything and had so little time because she spent most of each day taking care of her two bed-ridden, elderly parents!

Taking care of her aged parents!

Action Guide -- Idea Bingo!

Everyone Knows Something About Something

What's under your nose?

More on Getting Ideas for Your Niche

Stuck for good ideas for niches? Here's an excellent idea-boosting article from the Tips 'n Techniques HQ.

And this SBI! forum is an excellent spot for help from other SBIers...

Finding Your Niche (Day 2)

As a "newbie," you might feel a little intimidated, worried about asking a "stupid" question. Relax... there's no such thing as a stupid question if you're stuck. And super-helpful/friendly "veterans" have seen it all and love to help.

So don't be shy. Ask. At first you'll be asking for help. Later, pay it forward... help and be helped.

Action Guide --Smile That is what makes it the incredibly useful place it is.

It's possible to get distracted by everything in the forums. Here's what I recommend to keep yourself focused...

Go into the Finding Your Niche (Day 2) forum and ask your question (click on the New Topic button). Before you submit your post, add a check to Notify me when a reply is posted. Then get back to work, reading the Action Guide or doing more research. You will receive an e-mail whenever someone replies to your question. That's the time to come back and review the answer(s).

(Use that tip for all the other DAYs as well, whenever you have a question about something.)

Before you go though, I recommend that you finish reading DAY 2 so that you can take full advantage of advice in the Finding Your Niche (Day 2) forum.

The SBI! Forums are a must for any serious SBIer. If you have not yet checked into THE Place for Friendly, Success-Focused Discussion, do it now.

It's a great place for SBIers to help and be helped, to compare notes, trade ideas and strategies, and the list goes on and on. It's an all-star community ready to welcome your participation.

Get a quick overview of the Forums by watching this Supplemental video...

http://actionguide.sitesell.com/#Supplemental

And then log in with your username and password (found in your "Get Ready For SBI!" e-mail that you received after your order)...

http://forums.sitesell.com/

Read "Welcome From Ken Evoy" for an important, brief orientation. Then click around and explore. Jump into a discussion or ask a new question. The SBI! Forums are all about... Helping and being helped. Together, all SBIers move farther and farther ahead, faster and faster.

The best way to stay up to date with the Forums? Simply subscribe to the RSS feeds -- here's how.

Three Site Concepts? Why Three?

What if you only have one idea for a niche? Well, you won't have anything to compare against. In general, it's best to develop a "top 3" and then use Brainstorm It! and Niche Choose It! to compare and pick the best.

Only Know and Love One General Area?

Action Guide -- Love

Is there only one subject that really turns you on? For example...

Are you a jazz lover? Great! Develop 3 jazz-related Site Concepts for keyword research and evaluation...

"Jazz Canada?" "Jazz Festivals?" "Jazz Guitarists?"

There's more than one way to skin the jazz cat. And when you skin that cat using Brainstorm It!, you may find that one has great potential, one's a loser, and one is in-between.

Which would you rather build a business upon?

Developing ideas for your best 3 Site Concepts is important, so take your time doing this. Remember... the final concept will be your business foundation.

"Final" Is Not So Final

Don't let me scare you when I tell you how important your "final" decision is. It is, of course, important to try to make your best choice now, during DAY 2.

But you have lots of time during the deeper brainstorming of DAY 3 and the development and assessment of monetization options during DAY 4, to change your mind. So don't be afraid to make the decision and run with it.

Let's go... Pick the three areas that you love the most and that you think would appeal to others. After all, if no one is interested in your niche, you won't get much traffic. Without traffic, you might as well not have a Web site. You'd be invisible (just like 99.9% of non-SBI! sites)!

Already Have a Business? Refine It to the Best Site Concept.

If you have an established business, you already know the general theme/concept of your site. Now you need to determine the best way to approach your concept. Just like the jazz example above, you can "spin" any theme in many directions...

  • reflect what "solution" your business provides, or...
  • target a particular segment of your market, or...
  • deliver a specific angle, etc.

It's all about how you choose to spin it. Jot down some different Site Concepts related to your business.

And if your business is local in nature, see this TNT HQ article. Follow its advice and dominate your area!

Choose concepts that are not too broad in nature (ex., "travel" is too competitive). But don't make your niche too narrow (ex., that unknown off-off-island in the Caribbean) -- not enough people search for "too-narrow" niches.

The Goldilocks "just-right" niche is narrow enough for you to ultimately "master," but is also wide enough that there is enough Demand (i.e., enough people doing searches at the engines) for you to build significant traffic. Choose on the basis of "your gut and brain"...

Do Some Quick Research Before Brainstorm It!

Here are some common scenarios that deserve some "quick and dirty," pre-Brainstorm It! research...

All set with your 3 best Site Concepts? It's time to...

Step 2 - Use Brainstorm It! To Research Site Concept(s)

Action Guide -- Smile Yes, it's time for Brainstorm It! ("BI!").

Important Recommendation

For best brainstorming performance, we recommend the Firefox browser for PCs and Macs. Click here for details about this free download.

You will brainstorm keywords for each of your three top Site Concepts simultaneously. This will get the...

All Demand is not created equal.

Value Demand combines the number of times people search for a given keyword with its commercial potential (or what we will often call "monetizability").

For example, "anguilla beaches" has about the same search volume as "anguilla hotels." But are they equal? No. "Anguilla hotels" is a more commercial term. It can be monetized for a higher CPC through Google AdSense or through direct advertising by the hotel or even on a pay-per-lead basis.

Value Demand blends "monetizability" into raw search volumes, resulting in a Demand that better reflects the opportunity that a keyword presents.

How does it do this? It uses a combination of Wordtracker data and proprietary data from our SBIder's extensive spidering of billions of Web pages.

You still have to judge Value Demand in the light of your own circumstances. For example, "anguilla villa" is a solid word with good Value Demand for a site whose theme is Anguilla. However, the opportunity it presents becomes much more valuable if you own a villa and want to rent it!

Also, like any number delivered by computer algorithm, weird words and values can creep in. Wordtracker, Keyword Discovery, the Google keyword tool all deliver words or values that don't make sense. This can happen for a variety of reasons... spammers, automated bots, etc.

Brainstorm It! does an excellent job of delivering a complete set of keywords, and Value Demand is a more useful indicator than mere raw search volume. But it's not perfect and can be fooled (ex., by excessive bot activity and skilled page spammers). So...

As always, use your human judgement to make all final decisions.

One tiny detail. We use the terms "Value Demand" and "Real Supply" to emphasize the unique importance and precision of these numbers...

But you'll see me using the terms "Demand" and "Supply," too, since saying "Value" and "Real" all the time gets rather tiring!

SiteSell's "SBIder" has spidered billions of pages to find out what businesses are doing online. SBIder doesn't just accumulate keywords. It only accepts good content pages and weighs each keyword according to how important it is for each page, adding up all the weighted scores.

The final tally is "normalized" to one billion pages, whether it has accumulated 2 billion or 5 billion pages. So if the Supply for a keyword changes over time, it provides a real indication of "competitive supply per billion pages."

Therefore, don't think of "Real Supply" as a certain number of pages that "contain" a keyword. All other keyword research tools merely provide you with the number that Google (or any other engine) provides (ex., when you see, "Results 1 - 10 of about 86,200,000" after a search).

Real Supply provides more than a raw count of all pages that just "contain" the keyword. It's more fine-tuned. It's a weighted score that indicates how competitive one keyword is, compared to the others in your Master Keyword List.

Real Supply numbers differ from those provided by Search Engines, and not by any constant factor. "Bloat" accounts for substantial skew. Real Supply dumps the junk and spam pages from the total reported for any keyword. It dilutes the one-ofs. This leaves you with a "true/serious competition index."

That is Real Supply. The theory and technology behind Real Supply are rigorous, pushing the concept of "competitive supply" a quantum level higher.

Search Engine numbers include countless spammy pages that are not true, long-term competition.

Most pages reported by engines "contain" the keyword but are not "about" it. Those pages are not competition, either. "Page junk/spam" and "irrelevant bloat" greatly distort accurate reporting of true competition.

So you need a number that gives you a quick, accurate measure of the real competition for each of your keywords.

In a world of "Supply Sledgehammers," you have a "Real Supply Scalpel."

One tiny detail. We use the terms "Value Demand" and "Real Supply" to emphasize the unique importance and precision of these numbers...

But you'll see me using the terms "Demand" and "Supply," too, since saying "Value" and "Real" all the time gets rather tiring!

Let's get started! Action Guide -- Running

Brainstorm Keywords for Your Three Site Concepts

Brainstorm It! is the best keyword brainstorming and researching tool in the world, loaded with dynamic, robust resources. It's composed of two major sections...

  1. Brainstormer (where you do the actual brainstorming)
  2. Master Keyword List (where you do further research, and analysis).

1. Brainstormer

Time to use the Brainstormer! Go to the following URL...

http://sbiapps.sitesell.com/brainstormit/

Log in with your username and password (provided in your "Get Ready for Site Build It!" e-mail).

If you were already using Brainstorm It! and now you don't see its Web page, it is likely tucked "underneath" this Action Guide page, or in a different tab if you are using tabbed browsing.

Brainstormer offers a variety of powerful brainstorming resources. Each resource (also called a "query") always starts with the same 2 STEPs...

STEP 1 Select a Brainstormer Function.

STEP 2 Select a Brainstormer Resource.

STEP 1 and STEP 2

Important Note

SBI! refers to a Brainstorm It! 2-step combination of Function and Resource (or "brainstorm") in the following format...

Function (STEP 1) > Resource (STEP 2)

For example, your initial brainstorm (discussed below) will be...

Vertical Brainstorm > Site Concept Finder

After you select STEPs 1 and 2, read the text in the gray area to the right of the resource to learn more about each particular resource. You will also receive important STEP 3 instructions on what to do next. (Do this the first time you try every new query at Brainstormer.)

In-context help

That's all there is to it. Now let's "walk through" an example of the brainstorming process, step by step, for three possible Site Concepts, "Anguilla" (a Caribbean island), "Antigua" (another Caribbean island), and "Caribbean" itself.

STEP 1) Select Vertical Brainstorm.

Vertical Brainstorming generates keywords that contain the Brainstorm Seed Word (ex., if you enter "anguilla," all brainstormed words will contain "anguilla" in them).

Lateral Brainstorming generates keywords that are related to the Brainstorm Seed Word but do not contain it (ex., if you enter "anguilla," an example of a lateral word is "caribbean").

Vertical brainstorming is the most important of the Brainstormer options.

Brainstorm It! offers three types of Vertical brainstorming. Read the text in the gray area after clicking on each resource in Brainstormer to understand the difference between the Site Concept Finder and "Singular OR Plural" and "Singular AND Plural" vertical brainstorms.

STEP 2) Select Site Concept Finder.

Important Note

The Site Concept Finder is only available if you have fewer than 251 keywords in your Master Keyword List, and you have not yet registered your domain name. If you delete enough keywords to get below the 251 limit, and you don't have a domain name, the Site Concept Finder will become available to you again in Brainstormer.

The Site Concept Finder automatically brings back up to 333 keywords for each of 3 Site Concepts, or up to 500 keywords for each of 2 Site Concepts, or up to 800 keywords if you enter only one Site Concept. Brainstormer returns only the best keywords, the ones with the highest Demand.

This makes it easier for you to compare each Site Concept, since each one already has only the top keywords (based on Value Demand).

SBI! provides 25 free Wordtracker credits to use during your Vertical brainstorms. The Site Concept Finder query uses 1 credit for each Seed Word you enter.

Vertical brainstorming is your most important way to elaborate and evaluate your niche. So do not "skimp" to save a dime here and there.

Use it -- the pennies it costs will be returned a thousand-fold.

STEP 2

As soon as you make your STEP 2 selection, STEP 3 appears immediately below it. Before doing STEP 3, review the in-context help in the gray area on the right.

STEP 3) Enter your three Site Concept Keywords (see "anguilla," "antigua" and "caribbean" - without the quotes - in the screenshot below) and click on the Brainstorm It! button...

STEP 1, STEP 2 and STEP 3

If any of your potential Site Concepts can have a plural, and you want to brainstorm on the plural form, simply add a check beside the word. Brainstormer will then search for keywords containing the singular form and the plural form.

screenshot

In the example above, "clothes" and "pants" have no singular form, so the plural is entered as the Seed Word. "Shirt" is the singular form, so this brainstorm is asking for keywords that contain either "shirt" or "shirts."

If you want to brainstorm on both forms, always enter the singular in the field, and then add a check for the plural form.

After any Brainstormer query, you end up at the Master Keyword List...

The Master Keyword List

The keywords just added by your query will always appear in blue, as in the screenshot above. If you log out of Brainstorm It! and then return, all the keywords will be black. And if you run a new brainstorm (ex., on DAY 3, you will use the Lateral Brainstormer), the existing keywords will turn black, and the newest set will be blue.

Now it's your turn. Return to Brainstormer and do the Site Concept Finder brainstorm for your three potential Site Concepts.

...

2. The Master Keyword List

Congratulations! You have made great progress. You now have a Master Keyword List (similar to the one in the screenshot above), an excellent list of keywords, all related (vertically) to one of the three Site Concept Keywords that you entered.

The Master Keyword List (MKL) is the "analytical half" of Brainstorm It!. It is where you filter, sort, analyze and delete the keywords generated and researched by the creative half, Brainstormer.

Take the time to read the online help, which explains all of the MKL's functionality and covers the fine points of interpreting the data. As we discuss a different MKL tool here in the Action Guide, read the corresponding question help so you learn how to really get the most out of the MKL.

Your DAY 2 goal is to identify your best Site Concept. You started the process by finding some great keywords with Brainstormer. Now it's time to analyze those keywords.

The MKL allows you to study all 3 Site Concepts simultaneously, sifting out the ones that are too broad or too narrow, while zooming in on the ones that are profitable and fall inside your Site Concept Tolerance Range.

Site Concept Tolerance Range

Wondering which Site Concept is a good one? That's a question only you can answer, based on factors that make up your "Site Concept Tolerance Range."

  • How much time do you have (or do you think you have) every week to work on your site? To win a niche with a high Real Supply (250,000-500,000 range) will likely need at least 10-30 hours per week to succeed.

    If you have only 2-10 hours per week to work on your site, Supply (competition) needs to be lower, under 200,000 (the lower your available time, the lower the Supply should be). Of course, your maximum income will be lower too. You may start to see income sooner in an easier-to-win niche, but your income limit is lower.

    It's a natural trade-off. The laws of business dictate that you can't build a $200,000/year business on 2 hours per week. However, you can build a surer-but-smaller income with a smaller niche, and then devote more time to building a larger, second business. One realistic tortoise step at a time!

  • How monetizable is this Site Concept? If you are selling a product that earns $1,000 from each sale, you will need fewer customers to earn a good income, so you can afford to "work" narrow niches (ex., "Scottsdale real estate"). Product-oriented sites ("Product Focused Content Sites" such as review and other product sites) tend to pay more per click if you put AdSense or other ads on your site (more on this later). But these types of sites can be boring work, which brings up the next two considerations...

  • Are you passionate about the niche? If you are, the hours you invest working on your site will fly by, making the process "fun" instead of "work."

  • Are you knowledgeable about this niche? If not, you will need time to research and learn about the niche. If you are, you will know how to write great content that brings visitors to your site.

Look for a Site Concept that has sufficient potential. You are looking for the right combination of winnability (considering your time availability), searcher demand and monetizability, while being a niche that you know and enjoy. This is a guideline. Everyone's Site Concept Tolerance Range varies.

Working across all 3 Site Concepts at once saves you time by letting you compare the strengths and weaknesses of all 3 niches at the same time. There's no need to flip back and forth between Seed Words. You will get a clearer picture faster.

If it turns out during your review that one or more of your potential Site Concepts do not meet your criteria, you can delete them (we will do it together later) and add others, including sub-niches from those same Site Concepts. For example, "Caribbean" may be too broad, while "Caribbean cruise" may be a better choice.

And if, at the end of your review, you find that none of your potential Site Concepts make the grade, it is very simple to start again with another 3, going either narrower, into sub-niches, or broader, if you started too narrow.

Follow this unique approach carefully. If you do that, you will lead yourself to your perfect niche. Here is a summary of the 3 main phases of analysis you'll do as you narrow down to your best Site Concept. Details will follow...

First Phase of Analysis (Big Picture)

Second Phase of Analysis (Winnable Depth)

Third Phase of Analysis (Overall Depth)

Jump to the tail end of Value Demand to see how many very low Demand keywords there are, and to see how low they go. The Site Concept Finder brainstorm started this process for you by culling out the lowest Demand words, bringing back only the top 333 keywords from a combination of SBI!'s unique keyword database and Wordtracker's database.

Check for "low-Demand keywords." The ideal here is to have no low-Demand keywords found by this analysis (i.e., all keywords present have higher Demand values). Having none or the fewest low-Demand keywords indicates that this Site Concept has more topics that are sought after than the other Site Concepts have.

After the 3 phases of analysis, you will probably be confident about the best-fit Site Concept for your business. A quick double-check using the optional Niche Choose It! (invaluable if you have any doubts that are "too close to call") will confirm your decision. Details below.

If nothing screams "Pick me!" then simply repeat the process with three new ideas or Seed Words.

A Common Question... What's Acceptable?

Action Guide -- ConfusedWhen you're just starting with SBI!, how do you know what an acceptable Demand number is? What's bad?

Good questions! First, an important point...

You must ultimately use your human judgement and not make decisions purely based on "the numbers."

OK, now for some general guidelines...


Not Too Narrow (Demand Not Too Low)

The keyword for your Site Concept itself should normally have a Value Demand of greater than 2,000, preferably over 3,000. If it's a new and growing area, accept a lower number, sometimes substantially lower (depending on your passion and estimate of future potential).

You should also have two or more other keywords that are near or over 1,000, and 10 or more in the hundreds (lower these thresholds, too, if this is a new or growing area).

If your Site Concept Keyword has borderline Demand and if you only have a few other words in the hundreds, its audience may not be big enough to sustain a business. If the brainstorm only brings back 50 keywords or so, you may not have enough "meat" to build a site of substance.

Of course, there are exceptions to all guidelines, and that's true here, too. So again, use human judgement. Ask in the Finding Your Niche (Day 2) forum if you are unsure. Or get private, one-to-one SBI! Coaching.

Here are some examples, chosen to illustrate the fact that you must decide based on your own circumstances and monetization plans...

Example 1) Monetization  If a keyword is highly related to your primary monetization plan and if each "sale" is high-income/profit, accept lower numbers.

"Scottsdale Arizona real estate" may have a very low Value Demand and only 20 keywords, total. But that's good enough to take to DAY 3 if "Scottsdale Arizona real estate" is your business. After all...

  • you will generate more related keywords during DAY 3
  • a single client is worth tens of thousands of dollars, and
  • Real Supply is low, making this an easy niche to "own."

Example 2) Low Real Supply  In general, low Real Supply is one more circumstance where you could be very happy to accept "borderline" Demand. So analyze the Supply data, too, before deciding (more on this below).

Example 3) Product or Service  You want to sell a product or service online and have not been able to generate any profitable Site Concepts related to the theme of your product or service? There is always a profitable niche -- you just have to find it!

Look at the benefits of what you want to sell instead of the features of the product itself. Look at different aspects of the theme. There is always a way to spin a theme, to twist the subject matter, to broaden or adjust, so that it is in demand. Carve out your own niche!

Example 4) Broaden Your Niche  Local business seems too narrow? "Early stage" niche has potential? Determined about a certain niche and want to broaden it a bit? Read the appropriate articles in the Niche section of the TNT HQ.


Not Too Broad (Supply Not Too High)

To consider if a Site Concept is too broad, let's switch to Real Supply...

Generally a Real Supply of more than 200,000 (for your Site Concept Keyword) should make you wonder if you have the time and resources to "win" this niche. It can be done, but...

The higher the Real Supply, the stiffer the competition.

A nice "sweet spot" area, if you are going to be doing SBI! part-time (say 2-10 hours per week) is a Site Concept Keyword with Real Supply in the 30,000-70,000 area. The lower, the better, especially if it's combined with many high Demand keywords. Higher than 70,000 is certainly do-able, and is especially worth the effort if good Demand is plentiful and if you are willing to put in a bit more work to win this niche.

Suppose you are really determined to build on a Site Concept, but it's just too broad? Here's a good way to narrow down and stay within your niche...

Find an interesting keyword in your MKL that's related to your original Site Concept. It will usually be a "smaller part" of it. And then... do a Vertical Brainstorm on it! For example, if "debt" was just too broad (and it is), delete the keywords generated by "debt" and try "debt consolidation." (More on deleting later.)

There are lots of tricks for narrowing down, including jumping ahead to DAY 3 and doing a Lateral Brainstormer on your Site Concept. You just may find a new, related niche amongst the keywords that come back. For example...

The Lateral Brainstormer visits the top 200 URLs that Google returns for the entered Seed Word. It brings back the keywords that other Webmasters brainstormed, excluding the keyword you entered (since keywords containing the Seed Word were already covered in the Site Concept Finder brainstorm during DAY 2).

If your Site Concept had been "Caribbean" (too broad), a Lateral Brainstormer query would find a keyword like "BVI" or "Turks and Caicos," and so forth. Pick one that strikes you as a good Site Concept and start the process over, doing a Vertical Brainstorm on it.

Time to get started on our 3 phase process. The First Phase is all about getting the big picture. We begin with Real Supply...


Phase 1, Step #1 -- Study the Real Supply of Your 3 Site Concepts

Your goal in this step is to see if you can quickly rule out any of your 3 potential Site Concepts as either too competitive (too broad) or too narrow (very little overall Supply, which often indicates a niche without enough opportunity for income).

Guidelines for Value Demand and Real Supply

Ideally, your Site Concept Keyword should have a Value Demand of at least 2,000-3,000, with several more words above 1,000 (the more, the better).

Real Supply for your Site Concept Keyword should be below 200,000. The "sweet spot" (where it's fairly easy to win a niche) is 30,000-70,000.

However, these numbers will vary depending on the time you have available, how knowledgeable and passionate you are about the niche, and how monetizable it is (in other words, whether it fits within your Site Concept Tolerance Range).

A word of caution...

Do not be too quick to dismiss or delete a Site Concept if it looks too broad. There may be a sub-niche contained within it that you might miss without a closer look at the keywords, as you will see with the "Caribbean" and "Caribbean cruise" example below.

The first step is easy...

In your MKL, click on the Real Supply label at the top of its column of numbers. That will sort the keywords with lowest Supply at the top. Click again to see the words sorted by Supply with highest at the top.

Sorting

You could also achieve similar results by sorting keywords. For example, instead of adding a sequential filter for low Value Demand, simply click on the Value Demand header. The first click returns the "best" (highest Value Demand) keywords to the top. Click again to bring the lowest Value Demand keywords to the top.

Play with sorting, and combine with filtering and sequential filtering, until you get a feel for the power of what you can accomplish with this. Later, you'll use these newfound skills to delete your less valuable keywords.

Sorting? Click here for full help.

You will see one or more of your Seed Words, your potential Site Concepts, at or near the top of the list (within the top 15-20 words), like this...

Phase 1 Real Supply

In the screenshot above, "caribbean" has Real Supply of over 900,000. You would need to work 80 hours a week for at least a year to earn some income with this Site Concept! Too broad.

You may want to rule this one out, but before you delete all the keywords associated with this Seed Word, let's check to see if there are any sub-niches that might be of interest...

In the Seed Word menu, select "caribbean" as the Seed Word. Now only the words associated with that Seed Word will appear in the MKL. They will already be sorted by Real Supply, highest to the top (all sorting and filtering parameters continue from Seed Word to Seed Word until you change them)...

Phase 1 Real Supply

There are two keywords with reasonable Supply -- "caribbean cruise" at 37,113 and "caribbean cruises" at 25,361. Plus there's "royal caribbean" at 46,794. With three keywords about cruising in the Caribbean, all with reasonable Real Supply, you have an indication of a good potential niche.

Now it's time to ask yourself if you like cruising and have any interest in it. If you do, you've found a new potential Site Concept to research. If you don't, then you can rule out that possibility. For now, let's say that you do like cruising.

It looks like we'll rule out "caribbean." That leaves us with "anguilla" and "antigua." Based on a Site Concept Tolerance Range top-end of 200,000, "anguilla" has a reasonable Supply.

However, the Real Supply of "antigua" is too high (235,000). Still, it's not that much above 200,000. Your tolerance range (and passion) might keep it as a possible Site Concept (i.e., you're ready to really work hard on this one) -- and profitable -- for you. We may rule out this niche, but for now we'll leave it in. Further analysis may show that this is a good niche.

Or if you decide that Antigua is just too competitive, repeat the same process for Antigua as you did for Caribbean, looking for sub-niches that have more "winnable" Supply (less competition). And yes, you find that "antigua and barbuda" has a Real Supply of 97,667.

While you're here, do take a look at the Demand for each of your potential Site Concept Keywords and scan the Supply and Demand, the resulting "Profitability" of each keyword, and especially the Overall Profitability of each niche.

Contrary to what some SBIers conclude, there is nothing special about the Demand number being higher than the Supply number, with a resulting Profitability over 1,000. They measure two factors in two completely different ways. Review Value Demand and Real Supply now.

More refined Value Demand steps will make decisions. This is just out of interest.

Here is our list of preliminary conclusions after Phase 1 (Step #1)...

  1. We have ruled out "caribbean" since Supply is too high.
  2. You like cruising, so "caribbean cruising" is a possibility.
  3. "antigua" is over 200,000. Anything close to 200,000 is going to take much time and energy. It's do-able, but are you ready for a major commitment? If not, you'll see how to narrow down in a bit.
  4. "anguilla" seems like a solid option.
  5. "antigua and barbuda" is a maybe, depending on what the next Phase reveals.

Select each of the other potential Site Concepts from the Seed Word menu and sort their keywords by Supply (high to top) one last time. Are there any other keywords with a reasonable Supply that could make a good Site Concept? If not, you're done.

smiley Excellent progress!


Phase 1, Step #2 -- Examine the Value Demand of Your 3 Site Concepts

What we're looking for here is the number of keywords with high Value Demand numbers.

Click on All in the Seed Word menu to return all the keywords in your MKL. Then click on the All Keywords button to reset your MKL (clear all the sorting).

"OK, What Is That "All Keywords" Button?"

I thought you'd never ask! All Keywords is the first of the four pre-set tasks in the "Task Bar"...

taskbar

Pre-set tasks work on whatever Seed Word is selected (including All).

The All Keywords pre-set task erases all previous filters and sorts for the selected Seed, restoring all keywords brainstormed by the selected Seed Word in alphabetical order. Think of it as a "Reset" button for the displayed Seed.

You won't use the other pre-set tasks until later, but click on each of this link if you can't wait to find out more about pre-set tasks.

Pre-Set Tasks

All Keywords was the first of the 4 pre-set tasks in the Task Bar. The other three are set to help you find particular types of keywords...

taskbar

A pre-set task consists of a pre-set series of filters and sorts. The first 3, in this version of Brainstorm It!, are common tasks. You can customize the values of the filters and the sorts after running a task... extra flexibility and power.

A pre-set task works on all keywords, based on your Seed Word selection. If you select All in the Seed Word menu, then these tasks work on every keyword in your MKL. If you select "anguilla" as your Seed Word, these tasks work on every keyword associated with "anguilla" (i.e., Vertical and Lateral keywords). So...

If you want to filter-and-sort or run a pre-set task on only Vertical or only Lateral words, achieve that as follows (in this order)...

  1. Make your Seed selection.
  2. Run your filters/sorts or your pre-set task.
  3. Last, either include or exclude your Seed Word in your Keyword filter box (to get the Vertical or Lateral set of keywords, respectively)

To learn how each of the pre-set tasks works, review this help.

We'll cover how to use pre-set tasks, along with filtering and sorting, to weed out weak keywords from your MKL a bit later.

Now it's time to use the MKL's filter tool. This tool does some "heavy lifting" during the simultaneous comparisons of all potential Site Concepts.

Filters

The Filter tool is useful for finding pockets of keywords to keep, as well as finding keywords to delete (ex., very low-Demand keywords).

filter functions

For example, to find the keywords with the highest 20% Supply numbers, first choose the "highest %" function for the Real Supply filter, like this...

filter functions example

Then enter "20" into the Real Supply filter box. This filter will bring back the keywords with the highest 20% Real Supply numbers. Properly completed, the filter request looks like this...

filter functions example

Filtering does not delete any of your keywords. It simply hides them while you study the ones you are interested in. When you want to see your "missing" keywords again, click on the clear link for that filter to display the keywords that were affected by just that filter.

If you want to clear all sorts and filters for all keywords for the selected Seed, click on the All Keywords button instead.

One of the most interesting things you can do with filters is "sequential filtering." For example, after you find the keywords with the highest 20% Supply, you might want to find the 40% of those high-Supply keywords with the lowest Demand. How do you do that?

Simply add another filter. Pick "lowest %" in the Value Demand filter, and then enter "40." You now have some of the poorest-Demand, highest-Supply keywords!

Play with filtering and sequential filtering, and combine with sorting, until you get a feel for the power of what you can accomplish with this. Later, you'll use these newfound skills to delete your less valuable keywords.

Full help on filtering? Click here.

Click on the Filter button. Filter boxes appear just below the column labels and the corresponding column of numbers, like this...

Phase 1 filter

Enter 1000 into the Value Demand filter field (the default filter is "greater than"). This automatically delivers all keywords that have Demand greater than 1,000. All the words meeting this criterion will appear immediately. Click on Value Demand at the top of the column to sort by Demand, highest at the top.

This filter gives us 152 words in the screenshot above, but how many come from each Seed Word? That's easy to find out. See the Keyword column?...

Type each Seed Word into the filter field under the Keyword heading of that column. Use "contains" (the default) to find the words that contain each Seed.

'Contains' Anguilla

"Caribbean" has 126, "anguilla" has 6, and "antigua" has 20. And what about the new words under consideration as potential Site Concept Keywords?

Well, "antigua and barbuda" has 4 keywords with Demand greater than 1,000. How did you determine that? By entering "barbuda" in the Keyword filter, using "contains." Using the same technique, you find that "caribbean cruise" has 19 words with Demand over 1,000, (a subset of the 126 found for "caribbean").

For each potential Site Concept, you now see "strong-Demand keyword depth." In other words, you know how many keywords there are with Demand greater than 1,000 for each theme.

As you check the number of keywords for each Seed Word, also look at the actual Demand number for the words in each set. You'll see that not only does "caribbean" have the most keywords, it also has words with the highest Demand. Next is "antigua," followed by "anguilla."

This is a common pattern. The higher the Supply (in Step #1, above), the more keywords you'll find with higher Demand, here in Step #2. Your job on DAY 2 is to find a Site Concept Keyword with a Supply range that is winnable and with a reasonable number of words with good Demand (greater than 1,000).

A Seed Word with too many keywords having Demand greater than 1,000 ("caribbean" in this case) is likely confirming that the niche is too big (except, of course, in the unusual situation where Supply was relatively low -- then you have a real winner!). In this case, it's quite possible that there is a good, winnable sub-niche located somewhere within that bigger niche.

Since both "caribbean cruise" and "caribbean cruises" show up with excellent Demand and winnable Supply, we would probably now delete the "caribbean" Seed Word (it's too competitive) and do a new Vertical brainstorm using Singular AND Plural to add "caribbean cruise," which will give us both singular and plural forms of the Seed Word. But before we do...

Use the Singular AND Plural query with Seed Words that have both a singular and a plural form. If you want words with both forms, use this search to add to your keyword list.

SBI! provides 25 free Wordtracker credits to use during your Vertical brainstorms. The Singular AND Plural query uses 1 credit.

Vertical brainstorming is your most important way to elaborate and evaluate your niche. So do not "skimp" to save a dime here and there.

Use it -- the pennies it costs will be returned a thousand-fold.

Action Guide -- Pointing Note: The only time you should do a 2-word brainstorm for a Site Concept Keyword is when the Demand and Supply are high. You can, of course, brainstorm any 2-word keyword later (ex., many people brainstorm their TIER 2s when looking for more ideas/topics to write about).

But right now, our goal is to choose a Site Concept.

By the way, 3-word keywords will trigger an "are you sure you want to do this" message, just to be sure. If it's a reasonable keyword, go ahead. Brainstormer just wants to make sure you are not wasting Wordtracker credits. For example, the term "bed and breakfast" will trigger the warning, but it may still be an excellent keyword, even a Site Concept.

Before deleting "Caribbean" from your MKL, scan your list of Demand-sorted and "Caribbean"-containing keywords with Demand over 1,000. You just might find an interesting sub-niche here. For example...

If you have limited time and aren't interested in cruises, "caribbean islands" is an intriguing possibility. Good Demand, limited Supply. It may take some brainstorming for how to structure this site, though, since it would be hard to rank highly for each island. But a vertical (Singular AND Plural) and a Lateral Brainstormer may just give you some good ideas.

The key here is not to write about each particular island, but to find enough to say about "Caribbean islands" in general, and topics related to them (ex., Caribbean weather, tropical food, etc.). An interesting, but dangerous concept to manage due to its general and competitive (broad) nature.

"The 5,000 Move"

If you really like the idea of doing something on "caribbean" in general, run the Value Demand filter for Caribbean words (enter "caribbean" in the Keyword filter box, using "contains") with a Demand greater than 5,000. Then scan that list of keywords, sorting by Value Demand like this...

screenshot

Caribbean weddings! Wow, great potential (at first glance). Good Demand, low Supply.

Caribbean recipes! Anyone for roti? Action Guide -- Smile

These are smaller niches, but they look winnable and profitable. If they turn you on and if you know something about them, they may be a great starting point for a new Vertical brainstorm after you delete "Caribbean." They may or may not yield gold...

Vertical brainstorming 2-word Seed Words can be rewarding or disappointing...

Remember that vertical brainstorming brings back keywords that contain your Seed Word. So, if you brainstorm a 2-word Seed Word, Brainstormer will bring back 3-word-and-more keywords.

There may or may not be that many 3- or 4-word keywords that contain a 2-word Seed Word. So it is also worth doing a Lateral Brainstormer (see DAY 3) to check if the niche rounds out into a site with substance.

For example, you may not find many vertical keywords for "Caribbean recipe" (Singular AND Plural) but you might find a lot of Caribbean recipe ideas (ex., "saltfish, papaya chutney") when you do a Lateral Brainstormer, as well as ingredients ("peppers" and "mangos"), etc. If you know and like this area, it's a niche!

The Flexibility and Power of Brainstorm It!

By now, you can start to see the power and flexibility of this approach. You not only can rule out niches that are too narrow, you can find new sub-niches in niches that interest you, but are too broad.

If any of the above discussion is confusing, stop here and re-read the sections above. Understand the concepts well enough until you can think and figure out how you can use these ideas for your potential Site Concepts.

OK, back to our analysis...

Comparing Antigua with the remaining Site Concept, "anguilla," and the "antigua and barbuda" subset, we find that...

The steps in this phase demonstrate the amount of thinking required before you delete a Seed Word or add a new one. Take your time. It's worth it.

At this point, we will delete "caribbean" because it is too competitive, and add "caribbean cruise." First we delete "caribbean" as a Seed Word...

  1. Click All Keywords (this is always your "start over place").
  2. Ensure that "caribbean" is showing in the Seed Word menu.
  3. Click on Check all at the top of the MKL. Click on the link to go to the next page and click on Check all for those keywords. Repeat for every page.
  4. When all the keywords are checked, select Delete Checked from the Select Action menu. This deletes all keywords that "belonged" to "Caribbean" and therefore deletes the Seed Word, too.

Delete Checked

Now we will add "caribbean cruise" as a Seed Word...

  1. Return to Brainstormer.
  2. Click on Vertical Brainstorm > Singular AND Plural.
  3. Enter "caribbean cruise" in STEP 3 and click on Brainstorm It!.

Repeat the 2 steps in the First Phase -- study the Real Supply and the Value Demand of this new Seed Word...

This new niche is winnable in terms of competition (i.e., its Real Supply is well under 200,000)...

screenshot

It also has a lot of high Demand keywords (i.e., greater than 1,000)...

screenshot

Now that we have deleted "caribbean" and brainstormed/added "caribbean cruise," let's see what we have by the end of Phase 1...

  1. "anguilla" is winnable, with acceptable Demand.
  2. "antigua" is winnable-but-difficult, with higher Demand. It needs at least a 20 hour per week time commitment for a year, although you will start to see income before that.
  3. "caribbean cruise" is more winnable, with better-than-acceptable Demand. A good find.
    Note: Re-brainstorm and do the first two steps of this first phase for any new Seed Word before continuing to Phase 2.
  4. "antigua and barbuda"
    Note: We have not re-brainstormed and performed Phase 1 analysis on this yet. We will continue with "antigua" for now. If it turns out to be too tough to win, we can delete it and repeat the process on "antigua and barbuda."

A Review of What We've Done in Phase 1

  1. We sorted by Real Supply to do a quick check of the winnability of our 3 potential Site Concepts. "Caribbean" worried us, but we found a couple of other potential winners.
  2. Next, we filtered by Value Demand (greater than 1,000) to get a quick idea of the depth (number of keywords with high Demand) and the intensity (how high) of the Demand for each of the 3 Site Concepts.

Both steps confirmed that "Caribbean" was just too competitive. But both also identified several potential new sub-niches for it. We focused on one, "Caribbean cruise," to show you how to repeat the process.

But depending on your time availability and interest level, you could have done the same with whichever appealed to you the most. You could have even decided to drop Anguilla and Antigua and decide between "Caribbean cruise," "Caribbean weddings," and "Caribbean recipes."

By the way, make a note about all possible Site Concepts. You just may come back to them after you do a detailed Monetization study on DAY 4.

smiley Solid, methodical progress! Now we're ready for the next phase.

In the following phases, you review keywords and their data. You'll get ideas for Content or Monetization. As they hit you, type them into the Notepad for the applicable keywords.

notepad

Capture those ideas while they are fresh!


Phase 2, Step #1 -- Refine Your Value Demand in Search of "Demand Depth"

Let's re-use the Value Demand filter on "anguilla," "antigua" and "caribbean cruise" but with a lower number -- greater than 500. We are looking for Demand depth... a good number of keywords with sufficient Demand.

We get a total of 90 keywords -- 9 for "anguilla," 39 for "antigua," and 32 for "caribbean cruise."

This lower Demand filter of greater than 500 instead of 1000 brings back more keywords. Want to know how many of the 90 keywords are new words included with this filter? Do the following...

  • Change from "greater than" to "range" in Value Demand.
  • Enter 500 and 1000 as the lower and higher values.
  • Use "contains" and enter each of the Site Concept Keywords in the Keyword filter.

Tip to find newly filtered keywords

This will show us how many words were returned by the greater than 500 filter minus the number returned by the greater than 1,000 filter.

Now we'll see how steadily the number of keywords with solid Value Demand grows for each potential Site Concept. Repeat the above process with a range of 250 to 500 for Value Demand -- "anguilla" brings back 17, "antigua" brings back 38 keywords, and "caribbean cruise" brings back 54.

Note how deep each potential Site Concept goes... does the number of acceptable keywords increase nicely as you "stretch" your Value Demand?

So what's our conclusion here? Well, they are all good. "Caribbean cruise" has the most depth, but "anguilla" is looking good, and "antigua" is a happy medium.

However, there is a downside to "antigua." Yes, there is a lot of Demand, but Supply is also very high. So we decide to remove "antigua" since we're just not ready to commit that much time to winning a niche that is this competitive. Instead, we choose to narrow the Site Concept down to the sub-niche of "antigua and barbuda."

Why didn't we take Antigua out right at the beginning? Great question!

We could have, actually. But if you really like a niche, and if the Supply is likely too high, it can be a good idea to take it to the next phase. You never know when you'll find a great sub-niche. Or perhaps you'll find so many related high-Demand keywords that have low Supply, that you don't worry about the ultimate "winnability" of the Site Concept Keyword itself. But now... it's time to wave good-bye to Antigua. Let's consider "Antigua and Barbuda"...

Repeat the Seed Word deletion process for "antigua." And then do a Singular OR Plural brainstorm for "antigua and barbuda" (which automatically adds it to your list of Seed Words).

Note: You'll see a warning message any time you try to brainstorm on three or more words. You can safely ignore the warning since the Seed Word you are using is the name of the islands.

Use the Singular OR Plural brainstorm with Seed Words that don't have a plural form (ex., "mumps"), don't have a singular form of the same word (ex., "mice" is the plural of "mouse"), or have different meanings for the "plural" form (ex., "pant" and "pants"). If you want only singular or only plural words, use this query to build your keyword list.

SBI! provides 25 free Wordtracker credits to use during your Vertical brainstorms. The Singular OR Plural query uses 1 credit.

Vertical brainstorming is your most important way to elaborate and evaluate your niche. So do not "skimp" to save a dime here and there.

Use it -- the pennies it costs will be returned a thousand-fold.

screenshot

Why a "Singular OR Plural"? Because no one is going to search on "Antigua and Barbudas." They are only going to search on the singular form. Once we have done this...

Repeat the 3 steps above (evaluating Real Supply/competition, and assessing significant Value Demand, and then looking at the Demand depth).

Conclusions?

Here is what we have done so far (mid Phase 2)...

smiley Well done. You seem to be making a habit of relentless progress!


Phase 2, Step #2 -- Refine Your Real Supply in Search of "Winnable Depth"

Now let's take a closer look at Real Supply for "winnable depth." We are looking for the number of reasonably profitable keywords in each niche that have acceptable competition and are relatively easy to "win for" (i.e., "winnable depth"). The higher the number of winnable keywords, the better our opportunity to win this niche.

  1. Filter Real Supply with a range of 50 to 500. This filter usually brings back acceptable keywords that will serve as topics within our potential Site Concepts -- not our most important ones, but a good set of winnable keywords (i.e., good topics that may generate some of your earliest traffic, starting your growing traffic snowball).
  2. Also set the Value Demand filter. Set it to greater than 250. Now we have the subset of words with reasonable Profitability -- Real Supply/Value Demand. We now have 31 keywords that pass these two filters...
  3. Let's see how many belong to each Seed. Choose each Seed Word, one at a time, or enter each Seed Word in the Keyword filter and use "contains." We get 11 words for "anguilla," 1 for "antigua and barbuda" and 19 for "caribbean cruise."
  4. If you would like to see the Profitability of each set of keywords, click on the Profitability label to sort that column.

Sort by Profitability

Adjust the numbers of these filters if you want to explore further. For example, make the Real Supply range narrower, from 100 to 500, increase or decrease Value Demand, and compare those results with the ones from the first range.

Note: When picking your niche, we use absolute numbers in the filters. Later, when looking for keywords and working within your chosen niche, we will work with percentages.

"Caribbean cruise" has more keywords in this Supply range, but the Profitability for the "anguilla" keywords is slightly higher. So here is where your human judgement comes in. Do you go with more keywords with lower Profitability, or fewer keywords with higher Profitability? Which excites you more, Anguilla or Caribbean cruising?

"Antigua and barbuda," with only a single keyword here, is looking less likely to be your final Site Concept.

smileyYet more progress! You are definitely forming opinions and drawing near the end of your decision-making process.


Phase 3 -- Determine Overall Depth

Select All in the Seed Word menu and click on All Keywords. By now you know this clears your MKL, bringing back all words for all seeds and clearing all sorts, filters, etc.

For this final phase, it's important to remember that each of the 3 Site Concepts used the "Site Concept Finder" (or a new Vertical brainstorm for a Site Concept that replaced a deleted Site Concept). So each should have brought back up to 333 keywords. Therefore...

An examination of the lowest Demand keywords will yield much "overall depth" information about each niche. Here's how...

First, click on each Seed Word in your Seed Word list. Did any Seed deliver far fewer keywords than the others (a lot less than 333 keywords). If so, that Seed is very shallow. (The combined Wordtracker and SBI! database literally could find no more!)

Next, select All in the Seed Word menu to bring back all the keywords in your list. Then click twice on the Value Demand label to view the lowest Demand words at the top. Now examine these lowest-Demand keywords...

Phase 3

Note...

  1. All these "bottom of the Demand barrel" keywords belong to "antigua and barbuda."
  2. The Demand values here are very low.

You have to scroll all the way until Demand is over 40 before you start seeing some keywords that belong to other niches. You can test this observation by filtering Value Demand (choose "less than" and type in 40 -- they are all "antigua and barbuda" words). There is a big "depth gap" between "antigua and barbuda" and the other two Site Concepts.

At this point, you could delete "antigua and barbuda." But remember the Site Concept Tolerance Range? Key factors were your time availability, monetizability, passion, and knowledge. Those factors affect a decision that you might otherwise make purely on the basis of numbers. It's always wiser to put your efforts into winning a smaller niche that you love than struggling to compete in a niche that's too broad that you are lukewarm about. So...

If you only have 2-5 hours a week, and if you really know and love Antigua, this could be a nice little, profitable niche that you can win. Of course, "caribbean weddings" and "caribbean recipes" would also come back into consideration and may very well have more potential (all else being equal in terms of knowledge, passion, etc.).

But if you plan to devote, say 10 hours per week, to your site, "antigua and barbuda" limits the maximum compensation for this niche (unless you have a high-monetization plan such as selling villas, of course). There's just not enough good, in-demand content to build a business upon.

Let's stick with "antigua and barbuda" for now, for the sake of the following discussion. You'll see how a "smaller" niche may be the best choice. There's more to life and business than just the numbers. For now, though...

smiley You're done! Great job!

You now have a strong idea of the potential of each Site Concept Keyword. You have all the information needed to make the final decision, considering more than just numbers. It's time to...

Important! The "Vertical Keywords" Are Your Site's Backbone

You are about to choose your Site Concept (niche). No matter which one you select, the vertically brainstormed words for each niche are the most important ones.

In DAY 3, you will delete some that don't "work" for your niche. And you will add more keywords to your MKL, too, with additional brainstorms (ex., "lateral brainstorming"). But overall, you have just completed the single most important step of DAYs 2 and 3.

That's why you are ready to...

Step 3 - Evaluate the Key Factors for Each Site Concept

How do you decide which Site Concept is best? There is no magic formula, but you do have all the key factors and guidelines to aid your human judgement in making your final decision. And, as you will see in Step 4, you have an optional tool called Niche Choose It!, which will help you make that decision, should you need it.

A Caveat About Profitability

As defined earlier, the Profitability of each keyword is its Value Demand divided by its Real Supply (times 1,000). It can sometimes be misleading, as you may have discovered while analyzing the keyword data. Not all Profitability is born equal. For example...

Profitability that is high due to an extremely low Supply is not as valuable as an equal Profitability due to an extremely high Demand (and higher Supply). So do not be misled by flukey-type words with near-zero Supply resulting in high Profitability.

The ideal scenario is to identify good Overall Profitability... lots of keywords with high Demand (i.e., many people are searching for information on monetizable topics) and relatively low Supply (i.e., not much competition for that topic, but not too little either, which may indicate a statistical fluke or a nonsense-type word).

But even Overall Profitability is only one guideline to use when choosing the best Site Concept. Do not become profit-number-bound. Read this article about judging profitability if you haven't already read it.

Bottom line? You must use your human brain to judge the data that computers are blindly providing you. If you're unsure, ask for guidance at this forum...

Interpreting Keyword Supply, Demand, Profitability

And don't forget... help and be helped. Pay it forward at the forums -- help someone else in return.

Before going any further...

Grab a pen and paper, or open a text file. Score the three potential Site Concepts out of 100 for each of the 7 factors outlined here. You will be using these numbers in Niche Choose It! (Step 4 below), if you need to use that decision-making tool.

Don't gloss over this. Give each factor careful consideration and score each, out of 100, seriously...

#1) Overall Profitability Based on Keyword Research Results

Based on the analysis steps that you just completed, which Site Concept (i.e., which niche) is the most profitable. Ignore all other factors, such as how much time you plan to spend, how well you know or love the niche, etc. You'll factor those in next.

How many solidly profitable keywords does each have? (Remember... the Profitability numbers are useful, but use your judgement to make the final decisions.)

If it's a new and growing area, accept lower thresholds, sometimes substantially lower (depending on your estimate of its future potential). And if Supply is generally much lower for one Site Concept, accept lower Demand, too. But not too low...

For example, you may have 50 Keywords with super-high Profitability. But if they are all high because Supply is near-zero, then Demand might be quite low as well. That means that you'll have many Top 10 Search Engine rankings... but there may not be enough of a market to drive your overall business.

On the other hand, if your MKL is overloaded with high-Supply keywords, (ex., your Site Concept has Supply over 200,000 and lots of others in the 100,000-200,000 range), your Site Concept may be too competitive. Consider narrowing it down, using a keyword in the 30,000-70,000 range as a Site Concept.

By this point, of course, you should be grading "shades of gray," having eliminated Site Concepts that were clearly out of your range (ex., "too narrow" or "too broad"). But if you still have one that's "out of whack"... whack it!

You need a nice mix of reasonably high-Demand words, even if they have fairly high Supply, a few gems (medium Demand, low Supply) and many interesting "narrow niche" words (lowish Demand and low Supply).

Those "narrow niche" words usually provide the opportunity to deliver great content. And they will be the first words with Top 10 rankings at the engines (unless you get lucky!). They "prime the traffic pump."

As you can see, there is no way to reduce keywords to a magic formula. Numbers are good guidelines. But they are not the "be-all, end-all." Human judgement, knowledge of your subject matter, and gut feeling rule.

Profitability Not "By the Numbers"

Action Guide -- Confused Puzzled? Still looking for a formula to determine your best Site Concept? It's impossible to give a set formula, as much as we'd all love to have one.

Instead, use the general numerical guidelines above, and then...

You have to look at the interplay of the number of keywords, along with their Demand, Supply and Profitability, along with your own goals and time commitment, etc., etc. (in other words, what is your Site Concept Tolerance Range?).

Whenever you're puzzled, ask for help in the SBI! forums from SBIers who have been there before you...

Interpreting Keyword Supply, Demand, Profitability

Don't forget... help and be helped. Pay it forward at the forums -- help someone else in return.

Score each Site Concept for Overall Profitability and move on the next factor.... What else is important when picking your best Site Concept?

#2) Your Available Time

As was mentioned earlier, it is important to consider how much time you are willing to dedicate to your SBI! business. Be realistic. If things go as well as they should, you can always start another site, or figure out a way to grow this one further or to monetize it better than you may see today.

Score each Site Concept against how reasonable it is for you to master the niche, given your available time. For example, if you can only spend 2 hours per week on your site, you will do better, sooner, with "antigua and barbuda." So score it higher than "anguilla" and "caribbean cruise" (ex., 90 vs.50) since you are more likely to win at this smaller niche with 2 hours per week.

#3) Knowledge

Think about each keyword as the topic for a future Web page (since that is what it will become). Do you already know what you could write for those words? Obviously, lean towards the Site Concept that you know the best.

Real knowledge, straight out of your brain, shines through. If you have to research everything until you become an expert, that's a much more serious time commitment. It takes a long time to "shine" as someone who really knows what s/he is talking about. Have you really "been there, done that?"

#4) Passion

Just as important... which Site Concept excites you the most? Choose a less profitable Site Concept if the thought of building a site about it excites you much more! It will be fun to create interesting Web pages about the subject area and to do the necessary research to stay current.

It's not work if it's fun.

#5) Theme "Sexiness"

It's not just your excitement that counts. Some Site Concepts are more apt to excite visitors. Trust your gut feel about which would excite visitors the most.

It's easy to PREsell your way to a strong "Brand of One" with an exciting theme. Or make a niche exciting. For example, here's how one SBIer made knitting memorable... and important.

We'll cover this more on DAYs 5 and 6 and in Make Your Content PREsell!

Do you have an exciting niche? Can you make it so?

#6) Monetization Potential

Monetization potential is not the same as keyword profitability...

We have considered the former ("Overall Profitability") in the first of these 6 factors. Now we consider the latter ("Monetization")....

Look for a Site Concept that offers the potential for you to build several streams of income.  T  P is useless if there is no M potential!

You must be able to Monetize your PREsold traffic. And the more ways to do that, the merrier. How many of the following could you (eventually) implement on each Site Concept, and with what kind of financial potential?...

Is AdSense going to be an important part of your monetization plan? If so...

Use the free Google AdWords Keyword Tool to fully explore the monetary potential of your three Site Concepts. Here's how. Or watch the video explanation on how to use it (find it under DAY 2 of the Video Action Guide).

This tool will tell you what the going rate is to advertise for a particular keyword with Google AdWords. The higher the amount, the more income you can make from AdSense, and the more income you will make in general from this niche (since the high advertising costs indicate that the keyword is a valuable one).

Remember, the AdWords Keyword Tool is meant for advertisers, not for you. So the prices you see are the prices they pay, not the amounts you receive. Still, since you're comparing 3 niches, it's reasonable to conclude that if "Caribbean cruise" charges advertisers the most, the amount that you receive will be greater, too.

Do not make the mistake of thinking "only AdSense." As your site and traffic grow, you will be surprised at the monetization opportunities that arise. Think about it now and actively plan during DAY 4... so you can make it happen instead of being surprised!

You will cover these and other monetization models in more detail on DAY 4. Right now, consider the big picture. Be sure your "best Site Concept" has some excellent Monetization potential.

#7) Niche Depth

Overall Profitability (discussed above) takes into account the Profitability number (Value Demand/Real Supply x 1000) for all of your keywords. But the number of keywords could be 100, or it could be 325. Obviously, other things being equal, 325 keywords would make a better niche.

Niche Depth looks at the overall size of your niche, based on several related ideas.

First, how many keywords are there? A Site Concept with 300 keywords (after DAY 2) will produce a more substantial site than a niche that has only 175 keywords. The more content your site has, the more visitors it will receive, and the more opportunities you will have to earn an income from those visitors.

Second, how many keywords have high Value Demand? A Site Concept with 15 keywords with Value Demand above 1,000, and another 30 words above 500, means that this niche topic is something people are looking for. One with only 5 keywords above 1,000 and 15 more above 500 indicates a niche that's less popular. Your Phase 2, Step #1 numbers give a quick view of this Demand Depth.

How many keywords have reasonable competition (you can win at the Search Engines for those keywords)? If many of the keywords for a niche fall into the 50-500 range, then this Site Concept should let you reach close to the top of the engine rankings. A review of Phase 2, Step #2 numbers will reveal the Winnable Depth of each niche.

Third, how low does the Demand go? If it drops to 1 or 5 or 10 for a lot of keywords, then this Site Concept may not have enough to sustain it for the long run. If Demand drops to 40 or 50, and only for a few keywords, this niche likely has the "legs" to go the distance for you, developing into a site that draws large numbers of visitors. Phase 3 numbers show you this Overall Depth.

Your choice now may be obvious, based on the scoring and thinking you have just done. If so, congratulations! You are ready to move on to DAY 3, where you will build up a full list of keywords related to your niche. These keywords will be the topics of the Web pages that will become your site, which will drive your business.

Before you move to DAY 3... Are you unsure of your Site Concept choice? Do you want to double-check that your chosen Site Concept really does beat out the other two?

Niche Choose It! is objective and sophisticated decision-making software. It leaves no room for bias, no room for error...

Step 4 - Use Niche Choose It! to find the best Site Concept for you.

Action Guide -- ThinkingOK, It's Decision-Making Time!

The scores you recorded in Step 3 should result in a table that looks something like this...

  Anguilla Caribbean cruise Antigua and Barbuda
Overall Profitability Based on Keyword Research Results 95 95 70
Your Time 70 50 90
Knowledge 90 60 70
Passion 100 70 60
Theme "Sexiness" 95 85 85
Monetization Potential 90 90 80
Niche Depth 95 95 75

Once you have your grid set up and scored like this, you are ready to choose your best Site Concept. There are two ways you can do this, but the important point is that you really think about each of the 7 key factors. Is the score you gave each factor accurate? Were you honest with yourself when you scored the Knowledge and Passion factors?

You can compare the grid totals on your own and determine which Site Concept is best for you. But Niche Choose It!'s software uses decision-making logic and will not only make a more accurate decision, but will lead you through the reasoning in a more rigorous manner.

So Niche Choose It!, while optional, is highly recommended.

Bring your scores with you to Niche Choose It! and let it do all the "heavy lifting." Click on the Quick Tour Me Through An Example button...

That automatically takes you through a sample niche-choosing exercise. Follow the exercise through to its conclusion.

Then do it "for real." The easiest way is to simply re-use the example and change the entries as you go along.

In Step 2, enter your potential Site Concepts. Although there is room for five (and you can even add more to compare), enter the three that you currently have.

In Step 3, enter the factors above (or others, if you like) and weight how important each one is to you.

In Step 4, enter all of the scores from your grid above. By now, Niche Choose It! should look like this...

A final click takes you to the fifth and final step which answers your all-important question, "Which Site Concept should I choose for my new SBI! site?"

And the winner is Anguilla! This Netrepreneur has done the perfect research, analyzed it, entered her analysis into Niche Choose It!, and emerged with the perfect Site Concept for her.

Time for you to do the same.

Go to Niche Choose It! and find your best Site Concept.

Come back here after you're finished with Niche Choose It! and you know your best Site Concept.

...

...

Back? Great! I hope Niche Choose It! cleared things up for you. That little module has a funny way of helping matters make sense.

And that brings us to the end of DAY 2. You have systematically gathered data and analyzed all factors completely to select the most profitable-looking and interesting/fun and "monetizable" Site Concept from your three.

Moving Forward...

Action Guide puzzled

Overwhelmed? Not ready to decide? Just can't find one? The one you want is too narrow? Or too broad?

If that's you, don't worry. You are not alone. Some people really feel "stuck" here. A swirl of numbers. So many things to think about, new concepts and tools learned but not mastered. Phew!

Action Guide -- Smile I have good news... They succeed and you will, too.

You can do this. Each little step is do-able. There is lots of help in the forums (see links above and below). Don't be shy, it really is the friendliest, most helpful spot on the Web.

Remember when I said (above), "It takes work to build a real business"? Keep that perspective. This is worth the effort.

The "extra mile" that winners run is that extra effort that leaves others behind. The "extra mile" is why so few ultimately lead the life they want.

These two articles by Ken Evoy will help you see the big picture, "go the extra mile" and get it done (because you can)...

If they handed out a manual for your life... (a forum post)

How I Almost Drowned (an article in the TNT HQ).

And these articles on finding the "just-right" Goldilocks niche will help too.

Video Action Guide

There's even a Niche-Choosing Video to help you if you can't seem to get past this potential Hurdle. Not everyone will need this Video, but it's here for you if you need some additional advice and encouragement.

Click here to view the Niche-Choosing Video (find it under DAY 2).

Where was I? Oh yes, you have chosen your Site Concept. Now it's time to move on to DAY 3. But before you do, delete the other two potential Site Concepts from your Master Keyword List. To delete them, simply...

  1. Select one from the Seed Word drop-down menu.
  2. Click on Check all to check all the checkboxes. Repeat for additional pages of keywords.
  3. Select Delete Checked from the Select Action drop-down menu...

Deleting a Seed Word

Why delete them now? Because it's important to focus on your #1 choice. If your #1 choice does not pan out on DAY 3 or 4, you can always re-brainstorm any of the other 2 or the others that you found along the way. It only takes a few minutes to re-brainstorm... now that you know how!

You will also need room to do some Lateral brainstorming, to expand your MKL with related keywords that do not contain the Seed Word.

Niche Find It!, the Seed Generator

Are you having some trouble coming up with "Seed" ideas? Can't come up with a great Site Concept keyword? Or did your original idea not pan out? Use Niche Find It!, a brainstorming strategy that matches personal interest with reasonable Demand and Supply that is "winnable" for your time availability, and emerges with some potential Site Concepts. Then all you need to do is repeat the DAY 2 process with those new potential niche ideas.

Keep Moving...

Do not get hung up wanting more and more data. All you need is in front of you, right in your MKL. Yes, take your time and think about it. But then...

Best advice?

Keep moving forward -- pick one. It is NOT an irreversible decision. The next two DAYs will either confirm your choice or bring you back to try another. (The actual "final" decision only happens when you register your domain name, on DAY 5.)

With that perspective in mind, please allow me to remind you of a small business truism. The two biggest mistakes made by most entrepreneurs are actually opposites of each other...

1) FIRE-READY-AIM -- the person who leaps before he looks. If this fits you, Ben Franklin said it best...

"By failing to prepare, you are preparing to fail."

In other words... ignore the preparation work at your peril.

2) READY-AIM-READY-AIM-READY-AIM -- the person who researches, then researches some more, then some more. For this person, follow Nike's advice...

Just Do It!

Put on your SBI! Blinders, as this TNT HQ article suggests, and keep going straight ahead.

Advance to DAY 3.